In southern France, drought, rising seas threaten traditions
In a makeshift arena in the French coastal village Aigues-Mortes, young men in dazzling collared shirts come face-to-face with a raging bull. Surrounded by the city's medieval walls, the men dodge and duck the animal’s charges while spectators let out collective gasps. Part ritual and part spectacle, the tradition is deeply woven into the culture of the country's southern wetlands, known as the Camargue.
For centuries people from across the region have observed Camarguaise bull festivities in the Rhone delta, where the Rhone river and the Mediterranean Sea meet. But now the tradition is under threat by rising sea levels, heat waves and droughts which are making water sources salty and lands infertile. At the same time, there are efforts by authorities to preserve more land, leaving less for bulls to graze.
Manadier Jean-Claude Groul fetches his horse at dawn to start the day's work at the Manade Saint-Louis in the Camargue, southern France, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
A marshland used for grazing semi-wild bulls and horses is pictured in the Camargue, southern France, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
“Here in Camargue the bull is God, like a king,” said Aigues-Mortes resident Jean-Pierre Grimaldi as he cheered on from the private arena stands, where he's watched competitions for decades. “We live to serve these animals … some of the most brilliant bulls even have their own tombs built for them to be buried in.”
Generations of “manadiers," or ranchers, like Frederic Raynaud, have dedicated their lives to raising the bulls that are indigenous to the region. Wilder bulls that can win prestigious fighting events are the most prized.
Hoof prints left by Camargue bulls mark a section of pasture encrusted with salt on the Raynaud ranch in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 23, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
The coat of a Camargue horse is pictured in the Camargue, southern France, Sept. 22, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
Raynaud, a fifth-generation manadier, has raised many such bulls on his “manade” — a term for ranches in the region — just east of Aigues-Mortes. His ranch currently looks after around 250 Camargue bulls and 15 horses that graze in semi-wild pastures along the coast. He fears that soon his much-celebrated cattle will not have lands to feed on.
“The sea level rises on our coast and takes more and more of our land,” Raynaud said.
Frederic Raynaud poses for a portrait with his horse Greco at the beach next to his ranch in the Camargue, southern France, Oct. 19, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
A dike built to hold back the sea from advancing into Raynaud's pasture is pictured in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 23, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
A temporary dike constructed by local authorities to stop the growing sea has sunk in on itself, the water passing right through it and into the manade’s pastures. The edge of the ranch is slipping into the sea. Land that hasn't been swallowed up is becoming unusable as encroaching waters make the wetlands more and more salty. Heat waves and drought, exacerbated by climate change, are also depriving the land of fresh water, allowing sea water to take over.
“We used to have the salt rising up on just on our land" nearer the coast, Raynaud said. "But now the salt rises up through the soil five or six kilometers (3 to 4 miles) beyond the shoreline where you can see salt encrusting over the vegetation.”
Local spectators gather to run with Camargue bulls in a makeshift arena that wraps around the medieval city walls of Aigues-Mortes during traditional festivities, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
A spectator takes pictures as herders lead a bull into an arena bordering the medieval city walls of Aigues-Mortes during traditional festivities, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
The sea level around the town of Saintes-Marie de la Mer in Camargue has risen by a steady 3.7 millimeters (0.15 inches) per year from 2001 to 2019, almost twice the global average sea level rise measured throughout the 20th century, according to the local Tour du Valat research institute. Warming, expanding oceans and the melting of ice over land, both a result of climate change, are contributing to higher sea levels.
Researchers added that the advance of salt into the soil would leave the land barren and uninhabitable long before the sea engulfs it. Some affected pastures have already become bare with little vegetation and the abnormally high salt content poses health risks to organisms not able to tolerate it.
Manadier Jean-Claude Groul's hat sits on the dashboard of his truck as he transports Camargue bulls from one pasture to another in the Camargue, southern France, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
A road divides pastures in the Camargue, southern France, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
People have always been attracted to the Camargue because of the abundance of species and resources it contains despite the challenges of living between the ebb and flow of an ever-evolving delta. Its nutrient-rich wetlands contain an enormous amount of biodiversity, making it one of the most productive ecosystems in the world.
Rancher Jean-Claude Groul wrangles Camargue bulls set to participate in the traditional Aigues-Mortes festivities into his truck in Camargue, southern France, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
Manadier Jean-Claude Groul operates an irrigation pump on the Manade Saint-Louis in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 22, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
The Rhone river has long served as the Camargue’s lifeline, bringing fresh water from the Alps and dampening salt levels in the Camargue. As rain and snowfall decrease, it's becoming a less reliable fresh water source, with researchers estimating the river's flow has reduced by 30% in the last 50 years and is expected to only worsen.
“Glaciers which are in the process of melting at an incredibly high rate have already passed the point of no return, so probably in the years to come, the 40% of river flow that arrives in Camarague will be reduced to a much smaller percentage,” said Jean Jalbert of Tour du Valat.
Stacks of hay stored for the winter months to come sit in a silo at the Manade Saint-Louis in Camargue, southern France, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
A Camargue horse grazes on a pasture at the Manade Saint-Louis in Camargue, southern France, Oct. 10, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
During summers plagued by high temperatures and diminished rainfall, the sea water can reach up to 20 kilometers (12 miles) into the Rhone river. During a heat wave in August this year, the Raynaud family’s water pump in the Petite Rhone, an offshoot of the main river, began pumping salt water. They were forced to move the pump farther up the river outside the perimeters of their own ranch to irrigate their land and feed their animals.
Local residents dressed in traditional Camargue clothes participate in the opening ceremony of a regional type of bull fighting in the arena of Salin de Giraud, in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 25, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
Bullfighters face off with a bull in the arena of Salin de Giraud, in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 25, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
The Raynauds recently bought 10 hectares (24 acres) of land to the north of their property to allow their bulls to graze.
“It isn’t that much for 250 bulls, but if one day there's a catastrophe, that will be a fall back if we ever are forced to start again somewhere new,” Raynaud said.
A flamingo brand is pictured on a Camargue horse at the ranch of Raynaud in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 25, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
Rancher Frederic Raynaud unknots the tail of his horse in Camargue, southern France, Oct. 19, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
Manadier Jean-Claude Groul already grazes his animals across separated pastures, taking advantage of the different conditions each offers for his cattle.
At the crack of dawn, he whistles as he walks through an open field until a group of cotton-white Camargue horses heed his call and emerge from the fog. Groul loads his horses onto a truck and drives from one of his pastures to another he owns farther down the road.
“One day if things get worse, we will have to find land further north” he said.
A cockade representing the colors of the Raynaud family sits amongst a collection of trophies awarded for triumphs of the ranch’s bulls in a form of local bullfighting in Camargue, southern France, Oct. 19, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
The Raynaud family emblem is pictured at the ranch in Camargue, southern France, Oct. 19, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
Less and less territory is being prioritized for the ranches as authorities work to acquire land destined for preservation. Christine Aillet, the mayor of Saintes-Maries de la Mer, has said statewide conservation efforts are putting nature over her townspeople.
“They tell you on TV that the Camargue needs to be returned to nature,” said Aillet, who is skeptical of schemes aimed at saving the region by limiting global warming and reforesting the land.
“The Camargue will be dry without fresh water” if such preservation plans are enacted, she added.
A Camargue horse is taken into a barn at Raynaud's ranch in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 25, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
A Camargue bull is kept in a holding area at Manade Saint-Louis before being transported to a bull running festivity in Camargue, southern France, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
Aillet favors measures such as increasing the number of tidal barriers along the coastline, which she says will help residents, but researchers say these ideas are only a temporary fix and won’t withstand the effects of coastal erosion and a fast-altering climate.
Scientists in the region say the Camarague risks losing both its economic and cultural worth as well as its natural beauty if interventions aren't taken to help curb climate change. Top climate experts around the world say sea levels will continue to rise and that drastic action is needed to stop making the problem worse.
“For the past five generations the Camarguaise lived with the belief that the balance of Camargue is and forever will be stable, but we are in a delta that is beginning to face climate change," Tour du Valat's Jalbert said. “This ecosystem, that we believed to be stable, is starting to show cracks.”
A melted sticker of a Camargue bull in pictured on a car windshield in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 25, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
Rancher Jean-Claude Groul disperses hay for Camargue bulls at Manade Saint-Louis in Camargue, southern France, Sept. 22, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
For Frederic Raynaud, how big those cracks get will determine whether he'll be able to maintain a ranch that has been in his family for more than a century.
“I’ve always been here, grown up here, the animals have always been here," he said. "Leaving this place would be awful but if one day the sea arrives here, we will have to go.”
A man adorns a statue of Saint Sara with jewelry in the church of Saintes-Maries de la Mer, southern France, Sept. 23, 2022. Saint Sara is revered throughout Camarguaise folklore and tradition. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
The tomb of a celebrated Camargue bull named Regisseur sits at Raynaud's ranch in Camargue, southern France, Oct. 19, 2022. (AP Photo/Daniel Cole)
